- Home
- Mortgage renewals
- B lender renewals
- Switch From a B Lender to an A Lender
B Lender to A Lender
Switching From a B Lender to an A Lender: How to Plan the Move
A B lender mortgage is often a bridge, not a destination. Maybe you were self-employed without the paperwork a bank wanted, new to Canada, or recovering from a rough patch with credit. If things have improved since then, your next renewal may be the time to move to a bank, credit union or other prime (“A”) lender.
- Over 18 Years of Mortgage Experience
- LicensedMortgage Agent
- 100+ lendersCompared for You
Back to the B lender renewal guide
I’m Nalin Jayaseelan. I spent 18 years at CIBC, so I know how banks look at a mortgage file. Today I compare offers from 100+ lenders for homeowners in Scarborough, Toronto and across Ontario. If an A lender isn’t the right move yet, it’s still worth a call: many B lenders will negotiate at renewal, and because I see rates across lenders, I can often push yours for a better offer. This guide covers what A lenders look for, how long the move can take, how to rebuild credit and document income, and what switching costs at renewal compared with mid-term.
Back to the B lender mortgage renewal guide
In This Guide
- What “A lender” and “B lender” mean
- What an A lender looks for
- How long it takes to get back to an A lender
- Rebuilding credit: what actually moves the needle
- Documenting income
- Costs of switching: at renewal vs mid-term
- If you’re not ready yet
- Lender guides
- How Nalin helps you move from a B lender to an A lender
- Frequently Asked Questions
What “A lender” and “B lender” mean
“A lender” is industry shorthand for a lender with mainstream (prime) underwriting: the big banks, most credit unions, and prime mortgage lenders. “B lender” or “alternative lender” refers to lenders that accept files A lenders usually decline, such as a lower credit score, income that’s harder to document, or a recent credit event. That flexibility can come with higher rates and lender fees, so compare total costs.
Read more
Some companies do both. For example, CMLS, Strive, MCAP (through Eclipse) and RFA each run a prime line alongside an alternative one. The lender pages linked below explain each one.
What an A lender looks for
Every lender sets its own criteria, so treat this as the general picture, not a checklist with fixed cut-offs.
Read more
1. Your credit report and score. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) says lenders use your credit report and score to decide whether to lend and at what rate. The main factors in your score are:
- whether you pay on time
- how much of your available credit you use
- how long you’ve had credit
- how often you apply for new credit
- past collections, insolvency or bankruptcy
Scores usually range from 300 to 900. Lenders don’t share their exact formulas, and the score a lender sees can differ from the one you see.
2. Income you can document. A lender has to confirm that you can afford the payments. Salaried income is usually the simplest to show. Self-employed, commission and newer income takes more paperwork (see below).
3. Your debt load. FCAC explains the two ratios lenders use:
- Gross debt service (GDS): your housing costs (mortgage payment, property taxes, heating and half of any condo fees). FCAC’s guideline is no more than 39% of gross household income.
- Total debt service (TDS): housing costs plus all other debt payments. FCAC’s guideline is no more than 44% of gross income.
Car loans, credit card balances, lines of credit, student loans and support payments all count toward TDS.
4. The stress test, and when it doesn’t apply. FCAC says federally regulated lenders such as banks require you to qualify at a rate higher than your contract rate. There’s one exception that matters at renewal. Since November 21, 2024, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) no longer expects federally regulated lenders to apply its minimum qualifying rate to an uninsured “straight switch”. That’s a move of a stand-alone uninsured mortgage from one federally regulated lender to another, with no increase in the loan amount or remaining amortization. OSFI allows up to $3,000 to be added for transaction costs, and the new lender still underwrites you fully.
That makes your current lender’s status important:
- Federally regulated: among the alternative lenders on this site, Home Trust, Equitable Bank, Haventree Bank, RFA Bank of Canada and Community Trust are federally regulated.
- Provincially licensed: MCAP and Strive. If you’re with one of them, the exemption may not apply, so I’ll check before you count on it.
5. Your property and equity. More equity gives a lender more room. The type and location of the property can also matter.
6. Your mortgage payment history. FCAC notes that credit reports can include mortgage payment history. A clean record over your B lender term shows you’ve handled the mortgage reliably.
How long it takes to get back to an A lender
There’s no fixed timeline. It depends on why you went with a B lender and what has changed since. Here’s how to think about it:
Read more
- Income documentation: this usually resolves when your tax filings catch up with your real income.
- Recent credit trouble: time and steady on-time payments help.
- A consumer proposal or bankruptcy: these stay on your report for a set period, and each lender has its own policy on them.
FCAC publishes how long credit bureaus keep negative information:
| Item | How long it can stay on your credit report |
|---|---|
| Late or unpaid credit cards and loans | Up to 6 years |
| Credit inquiries by lenders | 3 years (Equifax) or 6 years (TransUnion) |
| Consumer proposal | 3 years after you’ve paid off the debts in it, or 6 years after you sign it, whichever comes first |
| First bankruptcy | Usually 6 years after discharge. TransUnion keeps it 7 years after discharge in Ontario. |
| Debt management plan | 2 years after you finish paying |
An item doesn’t have to drop off your report before you can apply. Each lender sets its own policy on past proposals and bankruptcies, so I check lender by lender.
Work backward from your maturity date.
- 12 months or more out: get your Equifax and TransUnion reports, fix errors, and start paying down revolving balances.
- 6 months out: gather your income documents and file any outstanding tax returns.
- About 4 months out: compare options. FCAC suggests shopping around a few months before your term ends rather than waiting for the renewal letter.
When you shop, FCAC says that mortgage quotes from different lenders within a two-week period count as one inquiry with the credit bureaus.
Rebuilding credit: what actually moves the needle
FCAC’s guidance on improving your score comes down to a few habits:
Read more
- Pay every bill on time, at least the minimum. Payment history is the most important part of your score.
- Keep balances well under your limits. FCAC suggests using less than 30% of your total credit limit.
- Keep older accounts open if they’re easy to manage, since closing them can shorten your history and reduce available credit.
- Apply for credit only when you need it, and avoid several applications close together.
- Have more than one type of credit, such as a card and a loan, but only borrow what you can repay.
Check your own reports first. FCAC says checking your own report doesn’t affect your score, and it’s the best way to catch errors before a lender sees them.
Documenting income
What an A lender asks for depends on how you earn your money. In general terms:
Read more
- Salaried or hourly: recent pay stubs and a letter from your employer, sometimes with T4s.
- Self-employed: personal tax returns and Notices of Assessment from the Canada Revenue Agency, often with business financial statements. A lenders generally rely on the income shown on your tax filings, so your filing choices affect what you can borrow.
- Commission, bonus or variable income: usually a history showing that the income is steady.
- Rental income: leases and tax returns that show the rent.
Tell me early if any return is outstanding or under review. That’s usually the longest item to fix.
Costs of switching: at renewal vs mid-term
At renewal (maturity), there’s no prepayment penalty. FCAC lists the costs to check when you change lenders:
Read more
- discharge, registration, transfer or assignment fees from your current lender
- an appraisal, if needed
- other administration fees
FCAC suggests asking the new lender whether it will cover some or all of these. Your current lender’s fee schedule matters too. For example, Community Trust lists a $495 discharge administration fee for Ontario properties, and Strive lists $395 for an Ontario discharge.
Mid-term, a closed mortgage normally carries a prepayment penalty. FCAC says this can cost thousands of dollars. You may also face administration, appraisal, reinvestment or discharge fees, and you may have to repay any cash back you received. Some lenders offer a blend-and-extend instead. FCAC says to compare the total cost of breaking against waiting for renewal.
For most people moving from a B lender to an A lender, maturity is the cheapest time to move. Breaking early only makes sense if the savings clearly beat the penalty and fees. I’ll run both numbers.
Collateral charges. If your mortgage is registered as a collateral charge, FCAC notes that every loan secured by it must be paid off or moved before the charge can be removed. Ask your lender or lawyer early how your mortgage is registered.
If you’re not ready yet
If an A lender isn’t realistic at this renewal, don’t take whatever your current B lender offers by default. Compare it with other alternative lenders. Choose a term that lines up your next renewal with when you expect to qualify, and check the prepayment privileges, so you can pay down debt along the way.
How Nalin helps you move from a B lender to an A lender
- Read your file the way a bank will: your credit report, income documents, debts and equity.
- Build a plan to your maturity date, with the specific fixes that matter for your file.
- Check the stress-test rules that apply to your move, based on both lenders.
- Compare A and B options side by side from the 100+ lenders I work with, so you know whether to switch now or plan for next time.
- Negotiate with your B lender either way. If you’re staying for another term, I use what I see across lenders to push your current lender for a better renewal. If you’re moving, its offer becomes the number to beat.
- Be upfront about pay. On some alternative, B lender and private files there can be a client-paid brokerage fee. I disclose how I’m paid, and any fee on your file, in writing before any work starts.
Read more
Approval depends on lender criteria.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch from a B lender to an A lender at renewal?
Often, yes, if your credit, documented income, debt ratios and equity now fit an A lender’s rules. At maturity there’s no prepayment penalty, though discharge and setup costs can apply. Approval depends on lender criteria.
What credit score do I need for an A lender?
There’s no single number. Each lender weighs your score with your payment history, debt ratios, income and equity, and the score a lender sees can differ from yours. I’ll check how your file fits specific lenders.
Do I have to pass the stress test to switch at renewal?
Not always. Since November 21, 2024, OSFI doesn’t expect federally regulated lenders to apply its minimum qualifying rate to an uninsured straight switch between federally regulated lenders with no increase in amount or amortization. Other moves may still require it.
How long after a consumer proposal can I get an A lender mortgage?
It depends on the lender. FCAC says a consumer proposal comes off your credit report 3 years after you’ve paid it off, or 6 years after you signed it, whichever is first. Each lender sets its own policy.
Is it cheaper to switch at renewal or mid-term?
Usually at renewal. Mid-term, a closed mortgage normally carries a prepayment penalty that FCAC says can cost thousands, plus fees. At maturity you mainly pay discharge and setup costs.
Will shopping around hurt my credit score?
FCAC says mortgage quotes from different lenders within a two-week period count as one inquiry. Checking your own credit report doesn’t affect your score.
I’m self-employed. What will an A lender want?
Generally your personal tax returns and Notices of Assessment, and often business financial statements. The income you declare is usually what an A lender can use, so plan your filings with your renewal in mind.
What if I’m not ready for an A lender at this renewal?
Negotiate. Many B lenders will improve a renewal offer, and because I see rates across lenders, I can push yours for a better one. Pick a term that lines up with when you expect to qualify, and use the prepayment privileges to pay down debt.
Is it worth breaking a B lender mortgage early to move to a bank?
Only if the numbers work. Breaking a closed mortgage before maturity usually means a prepayment penalty, often the higher of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential, plus legal and discharge costs. Compare that total with what the bank would save you over the rest of your term. At maturity there’s normally no penalty, so waiting is often cheaper. Ask your lender for the penalty in writing, and try the prepayment penalty calculator.
Will my lender help me move to its prime side?
Some lenders that run both prime and alternative programs say they aim to. Eclipse says it wants to help homeowners progress to prime lenders such as MCAP or RMG, and CMLS lists an AVEO Graduation to Prime program. Ask your lender what it would offer you at renewal, then compare that with banks and other prime lenders before you sign.
Talk to Nalin about moving to an A lender
Renewal coming up, or want to plan a year ahead? Call or text (416) 271-4055 or book a consultation. There’s no obligation. You’ll get a straight read on where you stand, and if staying makes sense, I’ll push your B lender for a better renewal.
Nalin Jayaseelan, Mortgage Agent Level 2, Lic. #M25000275 | Fides Mortgages, Dominion Lending Centres, FSRA #13727. Approval depends on lender criteria.