- Home
- Mortgage renewals
- Mortgage renewal vs refinancing in Ontario
Ontario Mortgage Renewals
Mortgage Renewal vs Refinancing in Ontario: Which Path Fits
A mortgage renewal keeps the same loan in place at a new rate and term. A refinance is a new mortgage, usually because you want to take out equity, consolidate debt, or change the amortization, and it is approved under tighter rules, including the stress test where it applies.
- Over 18 Years of Mortgage Experience
- LicensedMortgage Agent
- 100+ lendersCompared for You
Back to the B lender renewal guide
These two words get used as if they were the same thing. They are not, and the difference matters on a B lender file. A straight renewal is often the easier approval. A refinance can still be the right move, but it is a new application, and I will tell you that plainly before we start.
I’m Nalin Jayaseelan. I spent 18 years at CIBC and now compare 100+ lenders for homeowners in Scarborough, Toronto and across Ontario. I negotiate B lender renewals, and I also place refinances when taking out equity or restructuring debt is the better path.
Renewal: same loan, new term
At renewal, the balance and the remaining amortization usually carry over. What changes is the rate, the term and some of the conditions. You can stay with your current lender, negotiate the offer, or switch to another lender for the same amount. FCAC notes that you do not have to renew with the same lender, and that if you do nothing the mortgage may renew automatically (FCAC, Renewing your mortgage).
Read more
A switch that keeps the same balance and remaining amortization, with no new money, is a straight switch. Since 21 November 2024, OSFI no longer prescribes the minimum qualifying rate for an uninsured straight switch between federally regulated lenders. Up to $3,000 may be added to cover transaction costs. Equity take-out is not permitted (OSFI, 21 November 2024 letter).
Refinance: a new mortgage, usually with a new amount or structure
A refinance replaces the current mortgage with a new one. Common reasons are:
Read more
- taking equity out of the home
- consolidating higher-interest debts into the mortgage
- extending or shortening the amortization
- paying out a private second, a HELOC, or a co-borrower
- moving from a B lender or a private mortgage into a new structure that does not qualify as a straight switch
Because this is a new loan, federally regulated lenders generally apply the prescribed minimum qualifying rate: the greater of the contract rate plus 2%, or 5.25% (OSFI, Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages). You should also expect an appraisal, legal work, and a full review of income, credit and the property.
FCAC notes that if your mortgage is already insured and you increase the amount or extend the amortization, a new mortgage loan insurance premium may apply. Tell the new lender about existing insurance so you are not paying twice (FCAC, Renewing your mortgage).
Doing a refinance at maturity usually avoids a prepayment penalty from the current lender, because the term has ended. Doing it mid-term can trigger one. Start with the prepayment penalty calculator, then I will confirm the actual method in your documents.
When each path fits
Choose a renewal when you are happy with the balance, you do not need to pull equity, and the goal is a better rate or a better lender. This is the path I use most often on B lender files that are simply coming due. I can still negotiate the offer, or switch you to another lender, without turning it into a refinance.
Read more
Choose a refinance when the payment problem is bigger than the rate, or when other debts are costing more than the mortgage. The Bank of Canada estimated that about 10% of borrowers who had a mortgage in 2022 had since refinanced, and that about 70% of those who refinanced extended their amortization, by an average of six years (Bank of Canada, Financial Stability Report 2026, Households, footnote 6). Extending amortization can lower the payment, but you pay more interest over the life of the mortgage. FCAC makes the same caution at the top of its renewal page: think twice before extending amortization just to cut the payment (FCAC, Renewing your mortgage).
If lower payments are the only goal, see mortgage renewal payment shock in Ontario before you change the loan amount. For the qualifying rules, see stress test at mortgage renewal in Ontario. To compare staying versus moving the same balance, use the renew or switch calculator.
I also have a wider Ontario refinance guide at mortgage refinancing in Ontario. This page is only about the choice you face when a term is ending.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a mortgage renewal the same as a refinance in Ontario?
No. A renewal keeps the same loan in place at a new rate and term. A refinance is a new mortgage, usually with a new amount or a new amortization, and it is approved as a new application.
Can I take out equity at renewal without refinancing?
Taking out equity is a refinance, not a straight renewal or a straight switch. OSFI’s stress-test exemption does not allow equity take-out.
Will I be stress-tested if I refinance at maturity?
At a federally regulated lender, yes, the prescribed minimum qualifying rate generally applies to a refinance. A same-balance straight switch can be exempt.
Should I extend my amortization to lower the payment?
Sometimes, if cash flow is tight and you understand the extra interest. FCAC cautions that the interest cost can add up to thousands, or tens of thousands, of dollars. I will show you both sides before you decide.
Is it cheaper to refinance at maturity than mid-term?
Usually, because you avoid a prepayment penalty. You may still pay legal, appraisal and lender fees. Mid-term refinances add the penalty on top.
Can Nalin refinance a B lender mortgage at renewal?
Yes, when the equity, income and credit fit a B or A lender. If a refinance would fail the stress test, we look at a straight renewal or switch first, and plan the refinance for when the file is stronger.
Talk to Nalin before you sign
If your renewal is coming up, or the letter is already on the table, call or text (416) 271-4055 or book a consultation. A conversation comes with no obligation. Send me the letter and I’ll compare it with what other lenders will actually offer for your file.
How Nalin gets paid
In most cases, the lender pays me a fee when a mortgage closes. Some files, including private mortgages and some B lender mortgages, can carry a fee. If there is a fee on your file, it is always disclosed up front, in writing, before any work starts.
Reviewed by Nalin Jayaseelan, Mortgage Agent Level 2, FSRA licence M25000275. Fides Mortgages Inc., operating as Dominion Lending Centres Fides Mortgages, FSRA brokerage licence 13727. Nalin spent 18 years with CIBC and now compares 100+ lenders for homeowners in Scarborough, Toronto and across Ontario.